I typically wear a 2 in Crew coats, and I feel this runs about TTS with most J.Crew things. I know a down coat isn't very exciting for most people, but for some reason I'm really LOVING this coat! I LOVE the tie belt, I LOVE the length (just right for running errands, etc...but still covers the bum!) I LOVE the hood, the color, the feel, the thumb holes.... pretty much everything!
Maybe it will go on sale eventually, but I feel good about getting the 25% off since I think I'll be wearing this a TON this year!